top of page
  • Wix Facebook page



I recently re-tasted CHATEAU LA TOUR CARNET 2015, which continues to impress. This deep ruby wine offers a delightful bouquet of fresh blueberries, cherries, and plums after being in the bottle for an hour. The palate is a harmonious blend of fresh and robust flavours, with a strong expression of Cabernet fruit on a well-structured base. The ample and fine tannins, Merlot fruit's generosity, and the length driven by excellent acidity contribute to its depth. The finish, with its impressive size, offers a delightful mix of liquorice, coffee cream, oak, and vanilla. This wine is a product and an experience built to last and improve over time.


The Tasting Team highly rates CHATEAU LA TOUR CARNET 2015, with ratings of JS93, NM 91-93, and DECANTER 90. This vintage is reasonably priced and benefits from a dynamic international distribution. It surpasses the 2014, 2013, 2012, and 2011 vintages, and the stock available in Bordeaux is notably limited. However, despite these unique selling points, the 2015 vintage is not fetching a decent price according to supply and demand principles, as with its other wines.


Unfortunately, this Magrez-4th Growth-Left Bank wine is undervalued in the Hong Kong market due to aggressive importing and price slashing, leading to oversaturation and an undervalued market. This situation is disappointing for a wine of this calibre due to the current market conditions.


Despite the challenges, it's important to remember that it's not the end of the world. Prioritizing consumer choice in the market is always valuable. While we may be small wine companies, we should strive for excellence, even in challenging market conditions.





We did the consecutive vintages of 2013, 2014 and 2015 because these wines of Tenuta San Guido Guidalberto from Sassicaia are market-proven. Vintage 2013, a benchmark year for the winery, is, of course, darn good; 2014 was a challenging year and tasted unique; this 2015 is as good either because this is a delicious second wine from an excellent vintage (slight rain, then hot sum, breezy; Jancis Robinson and Decanter).


With soft, plump tannins, this 2015 Guialberto exhibits fruit freshness (plum and black cherry fruit). Tobacco and cedar notes lead onto a subtle, tapering finish. Compared to the more challenging 2014 vintage, which gives soft, supple tannin structures and an excellent balance of acidity and freshness. Guidalberto 2015 naturally shows a more complex and intense structure when compared. Nonetheless, we find that vintage 2105 cannot measure up to the performance of the 2013 vintage at this point of observation. While more reviews and tasting are expected for the 2015 vintage, Decanter has already been awarded a score of 91(and the first wine, Sassicaia 2015, got RP93), and we hope this second wine fetches a higher score months down the road. Despite significant Merlot, the ABV is just 13.5%. This 2015 gives pleasant drinking now and charges only a tiny fraction of the First Wine Price.     


The 2015 harvest began with Merlot during the first week of September and continued with Cabernet Sauvignon from late September to late October. The hand-picked grapes arrived in the cellar healthy, crunchy, uniformly ripe with a spicy aroma of Winemaking. The very gentle crushing and de-stemming of the clusters of grapes is followed by fermentation in temperature-controlled stainless steel vats (between 30° - 31° C. This process uses the vineyard's native yeast). The skins lasted 9 to 12 days for Cabernet Sauvignon. Pump-overs of the musts and délestages followed it to soften the wine. Secondary fermentation (Malolactic fermentation) also occurs in stainless steel vats. Following the malolactic fermentation, the wine was aged 15 months in French and partially American oak barrels. It releases on the market after an additional few months. The vineyards, with their strong presence of limestone and relatively rich in clay, contribute to the wine's unique flavour profile. They are between 100 and 300 meters above sea level, facing south/southwest.


The scores are impressive; the comments are positive. For example, 95 Decanter Review Date: 03/2023, on which Decanter believed that "the grapes were of an excellent quality, perfectly ripened, pretty cool and crisp, giving wines with great structure and elegant, soft tannins.' This 2015 Guidalberto, served from magnum in which the wine tends to age more slowly than in the bottle, was just beautiful and one of the stars of the tasting for me. The wine is deeply coloured with intense, ripe, aromatic black cherry and blackcurrant aromas and flavours. Very bright and vivid, the wine opens gently on the palate with super-fine tannins and mouthwatering freshness. A lovely example of the vintage! 94


94 James Suckling, Review Date: 10/2017, who commented THE Fantastic fruit on the nose, with currant, apricot, and orange aromas that follow through to the whole body. Extremely fine tannins and a bright finish. This is a tight yet generous red with so much going on. It's the best ever.


93 Wine Enthusiast Review Date: 03/2018, on which commendation regarding very fresh redcurrants, blue flowers, cedar, and a hint of pine forest are some of the aromas of this fragrant red. A blend of Cabernet Sauvignon and Merlot, the bright, savoury palate doles out juicy raspberry, red cherry, tobacco and white pepper alongside fine-grained tannins. At the same time, a liquorice note graces the close.


92 Wine & Spirits Review Date: 04/2018 said this wine is fresh. Layers of relaxed mineral tannins infuse the wine with energy, guiding its flavours of plum, raspberry, and black currant as they flesh out to reveal notes of anise, tobacco, and green peppercorn. The flavours feel precise and tightly meshed, with plenty of freshness to merit ageing, but it's delicious now if decanted alongside seared steak.





Château La Couspaude is a Saint-Emilion Grand Cru Classe that has been part of the Aubert family's heritage since 1750. The 2007 vintage stylistics is unique, though. The 2007 fruit was expressive yet suppressed; it was the traditional approach of using new oak and extended oak fermentation. This process results in a wine with a light and soft texture, ripe red and black fruits, and an herbal finish on the palate. While it may lack some complexity, these unique characteristics make it a wine that still pleases the senses. It is elegant and exhibits a well-integrated grip with a medium mineral finish. This standard's high and consistent scores testify to its unique qualities. For example, WE 93 describes it as a dense wine full of tannins and black currant fruit, solid and concentrated. It has a dark, firm character with fine ageing potential. It is a well-balanced wine with good ageing potential and a recommended drink from 2023.


Andreas Larsson's 93 comment is as follows. Dense dark colour with a purple hue. Ripe nose with wild berries, cassis, fine oak, tobacco, and sage. The palate is ample with lush dark fruit, finely balanced by vibrant acidity and grainy tannin—Digest fruit flavours with finely tuned oak and a long lingering finish.


The Wine Independent also gave 93.


Château La Couspaude consistently garners high scores from wine critics, with most ratings falling in the 90-point range. These scores are a testament to the wine's exceptional quality and unique character, as recognized by experts in the field. The wine's distinctiveness, resulting from the winery's unwavering commitment to quality, will pique your curiosity and invite you to explore its nuances.


RP did not score this wine; he only scored the 2018 vintage, which was RP94. Old and new vintages blend roughly 70% Merlot, 25% Cabernet Franc, and 5% Cabernet Sauvignon from grapes grown on a 7-hectare vineyard with vines averaging 50 years old. Older vintages used aged oak to surface fruit in the 1990s, 2000s, and early 2010s. Newer vintages use new oak to increase species, structure, palate length, and complexity over the long term. Regardless of vintages, the grapes are hand-harvested in small crates and chosen by plot. This meticulous process, from the careful selection of grapes to the manual punching of the cap during pre-fermentation maceration and the 18 to 20-month ageing period, ensures a wine of exceptional quality and character. This commitment to quality is a hallmark of the winery and is reflected in every bottle of Château La Couspaude.


Many thanks to Olivier Sublett of CHateau De Roque. If not for Oliver Sublett's introduction to the Auberts, I would not have been able to taste La Couspaude vintages to that extent.  

Title. Double click me.

Beneath the amber light of a late afternoon, I swirled a glass of deep ruby wine, its earthy aroma permeating the air. With the initial sip, notes of blackberry and leather emerged, evoking a vivid memory of the vineyard of origin. This collection assembles my tasting notes and essays.

​

Composed between 2006 and 2013, these essays were originally published on Wine and Beyond and Yahoo, before the site's closure in September 2013. The disappearance of Wine and Beyond represented the loss of a significant chapter in my personal history.

​

Preserving these articles honours those memories and shares stories that continue to resonate. I have selected essays that best reflect the progression of my experiences in the wine industry, emphasizing pivotal moments and key lessons. Each narrative was chosen for its distinct contribution, whether by illuminating an aspect of wine culture or marking a personal milestone.


Over the years, my engagement with wine has encompassed purchasing, selling to wine companies, lecturing, writing, and, most meaningfully, sharing bottles with friends. I recall an afternoon in Bordeaux when a sudden storm forced us to seek shelter beneath the narrow eaves of an old vineyard cottage. Amidst the rain and laughter, a senior vineyard worker offered us a glass of Merlot he had personally cultivated. This simple moment exemplified the profound connection and shared experience that wine fosters.

 

If these articles resonate, it is due to the influence of my teachers, mentors, peers, friends, students, and especially my editors, who have inspired my passion for storytelling.

​

Rewritten 15 January 2026.

​

Kevin Tang

Recent Posts
bottom of page